Matthew Bucher

Living the Message

Matthew Bucher tries to make significant, lasting impacts in the communities where he’s involved. As the pastor of Immanuel Mennonite Church, Bucher strives to influence not only his congregation, but the surrounding neighborhood, which is primarily composed of African-Americans and immigrants.

In the midst of starkly negative political rhetoric surrounding these groups, Bucher envisioned a welcoming, multilingual sign as a way to support their neighbors in Harrisonburg, Virginia. Now, more than three years after the idea, the sign’s message has spread throughout the U.S. and even the world.

Even with the sign’s proliferation, its simple message is greatly informed by Bucher’s experiences and continuously re-enacted in the way he treats others. His life serves as a testament to his deep-rooted belief in those words: “No matter where you are from, we’re glad you’re our neighbor.”

“I came up with the words, but I really think it grows of out of my parents’ teaching, extended family, my time in Egypt and the teaching I received in this neighborhood and this church [Immanuel],” Bucher said.

Living on a small dairy farm in Pennsylvania, Bucher’s parents allowed their faith to dictate the way they lived and treated people. They hosted a number of foster children both before Bucher was born and continued to do so throughout his childhood, striving to provide a model of restorative justice for their children.

“I saw them modeling Christian love, I saw them modeling restorative justice. I didn’t know what it was called at that point,” Bucher said.

“A Lesson from His Parents.”

The farm was also where Bucher got his first tastes of the world’s diversity. Visitors from all over the world — including his sister’s friends from college, a foreign exchange student from Japan and numerous people from the Church of the Brethren in Nigeria — spent time at the house with the family. Bucher would also spend time with foreign exchange students that stayed at his grandmother’s house.

“I got to meet people from around the world and throughout our community on the farm,” Bucher said.

While studying at Messiah College, Bucher minored in peace studies, which allowed him to learn about social justice, war and peacemaking from a Biblical perspective. For his practicum, he went on a trip to Bethlehem and Hebron with Christian Peacemaker Teams, an experience he calls “formative.” They explored what it means to be “in the way,” a term with dual meanings. Early Christians were referred to as being “in the way,” but the group also wanted to explore what it means to put one’s body “in the way” of violence.

When he graduated, Bucher applied to Mennonite Central Committee (MCC), and they offered him a position working with a Coptic Orthodox Church in Egypt. Experiencing the hospitality offered to him during the four years he lived in the Bishop’s residence—where he frequency met other visitors from Egypt and around the world—inspired Bucher. The church looked to a story in the Bible as their motivation to show hospitality: Joseph, Mary, and Jesus came to—and were received in—Egypt as political refugees.

“It’s this place that is highly shaped by hospitality 2,000 years ago, and it continues to permeate even today,” Bucher said.

Post-Egypt, Bucher moved to Harrisonburg to attend Seminary at Eastern Mennonite University, where he earned master’s degrees in conflict transformation and divinity. He began attending Immanuel, and he started an internship during the fall of 2013.

That interest in peacemaking and racial inequality led him to try to understand Newtown and the factors that have impacted its current state, so he was always asking questions to community members. In an effort to meet everyone, he knocked on every door in the neighborhood during his internship. Even though not everyone answered, he was impressed by the hospitality he did receive. In July 2015, he both moved into Newtown — only a block away from Immanuel —a nd became the pastor.

Even though he himself was relatively new to the community, the positive reputation of the church and its members meant that he was already accepted.

“I am extended trust in this community because of connections folks have handed me,” Bucher said. “That’s an incredible gift.”

Although he did inherit some connections, Bucher has forged his own relationships in the community. Denominational and racial differences often cause demonization and disunity between congregations, but Bucher has refused to let happen between Immanuel and surrounding churches. He has built strong relationships with First Baptist Church (a primarily African-American church whose original building was destroyed during urban renewal), John Wesley United Methodist Church and Bethel African Methodist Episcopal Church. During the Easter and Lenten season, these four churches partner together and host different services.

“Sharing those services has been a really amazing way of being together, even though there are denominational differences,” Bucher said. They openly acknowledge their differences in beliefs and “name Christ as primary in our worship and life, even amidst differences.”

But it’s not just other Protestant churches that Bucher tries to connect with. He attends meetings for the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) and open houses at the local Mosque.

“On the Other Side of the Sign”

While giving the neighbors a message of acceptance was one of his original intentions, his reasoning was two-fold.

“I really meant it as a challenge, quite honestly, to my own congregation,” Bucher said. “It’s a blessing because the congregation was already doing this.”

As the sign has grown in popularity, some have misinterpreted its message as a political statement. When someone on Facebook challenged Bucher, claiming that the sign was political, Bucher responded in a rather unconventional way: he invited them to sit down and talk. By taking the time to have a conversation at a local coffee shop, Bucher was able to communicate what he couldn’t online:

“This is not a red [Republican] sign or a blue [Democrat] sign,” says Bucher. “We feel called as followers of Jesus to live this way.”

Up Next

The People